40 Gift Ideas for Church Members

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

It is nice to show our fellow church members that we care about them, and sometimes we do that through a thoughtful gift. Whether it is for a special occasion like a birthday, or just to let them know that they are a valuable part of the congregation, here are some lovely gift ideas for church members.


Our Best Gift Ideas For Church Members

Mug with a Blessing

When they are starting their day, let them enjoy their morning coffee in this lovely mug with gorgeous floral decoration and a thoughtful blessing on it. It lets them know that they are an important person in the world and that they are cared for by others. This premium 20 ounce mug is made from stoneware and is dishwasher and microwave safe.

Biblical Genealogy Chart

This is a beautiful gift idea for church members! It outlines the timelines, marriages, unions, aliases, and significant tribes. It also provides summaries of significant Biblical events such as Creation, the Flood, the Tower of Babble, the Exodus, and the Exile. This would be a lovely gift to have framed and displayed in their home!

Philipians 4:13 Engraved Pen

Everyone needs a pen to carry with them, and this lovely engraved pen also comes with an inspirational message engraved on it. It reminds the recipient of all the strong things they can do, with the quote “I can do all things through Christ who gives me strength”. This is a practical yet thoughtful gift that they will use and appreciate again and again.

Cross Leather Bracelet

Sometimes people like to show their faith through wearing jewelry or accessories. This leather bracelet with a cross on it is the perfect gift. It has a slip knot closure so it will fit any size wrist. It is made of soft material that is comfortable to wear on a daily basis. You can choose between black or brown leather, depending on the recipient’s preferences and style.

Wooden Prayer Box

This prayer box is such a beautiful gift to give to a fellow church member. A lovely wooden box, this item has a beautiful golden inscription on the inside that reads, “Write down your prayers, put your worries to rest, place them in this box, and let God do the rest”. The gift comes with the wooden prayer box, a marker pen, and 20 foil stamped blank cards that you can use to write down your prayers on.

Bible Carrying Case

In order to keep their Bible in good condition, this would be a very useful gift for church members. Through rain and poor weather, their Bible will be protected. This bible purse fits NIV study Bible and is made of 100% eco-friendly, ultra thick polyester felt with faux leather handles. Each bible case is handcrafted and comes in a wide variety of colors to choose from.

Christian Bracelet for Women

This beautiful rose gold bracelet for women is a piece of jewelry that one would treasure. With its two interlocking circles adorned with clear crystals and lovely engraving that reads “Trust in the Lord with all your Heart”, this bracelet is sure to become a favorite in her collection. It also comes packaged in a velvet cloth jewelry pouch, so it is ready to be given as a gift right away.

Stanley London Engraved Working Compass Necklace

A unique way of honoring one’s faith, this gorgeous sterling silver necklace pendant combines a functional compass with a beautiful cross overlay that says “May your faith always guide you”. It makes the perfect gift for that special someone, and it even offers the option to add a personalized message on the back.

Inspirational Scriptures Coaster Set

Protect your tables from wet marks with these stylish coasters that each have a different inspirational message on them. They are individually handcrafted from high-density ceramic, and they come in different colors. The coasters also come packaged in a lovely gift box so the gift wrapping is already done!

Bible Verse Blanket

There is nothing better than cozying up with a nice warm blanket, and what better design on a blanket than a heart-warming inspirational message? This lovely message reminds us that God always loves us, and it is written in beautiful print across a pretty blue and beige color gradient. It is lightweight and comes in three different sizes depending on what you are looking for.

God’s Promises Day by Day Calendar

It is nice to be reminded each day of just how blessed we are and how much God cares for us. This beautiful day by day calendar makes the perfect gift, as it is practical while also sending a nice positive message for the start of every day. There is a different Bible quote or inspirational message for every day of the year, and this calendar is designed to be displayed on a table top with its easel back design.

Roman Table Cross

This gift is guaranteed to impress! It is a stunning Roman table cross that is made of multiple large stones that each have a different quote on them. The quotes are very poignant, and the style of this cross is so unique. It is sure to be a conversation starter with its lovely messages and beautiful design.

Decorative Walk by Faith Not by Sight Porcelain Coffee Mug

Everyone needs a favorite coffee mug! Or, if they’re not coffee drinkers, then perhaps a tea mug! This beautiful porcelain coffee mug is sure to take that role in some lucky person’s home. On one side of the mug it says “Man of God” in front of a golden cross and shield, while on the other side is the quote “We walk by faith not by sight”.

Faith Cross Necklace

This is a lovely piece of jewelry that is as subtle as it is pretty. The word “faith” is written down the longside of a cross made of premium stainless steel. At the bottom of the card that the necklace comes on is the message, “Faith does not make things easy. It makes them possible.” This is important for us all to remember, and this gift would surely be appreciated by many.

Inspirational Trinket Dish

If you are anything like me, you need a trinket dish to keep your special items in or they end up left on a window sill or in the shower (or is that just me?). This charming trinket dish measures 4” x 4” and can be used to hold rings, earrings, hair clips, etc. There are 6 different motivational messages that you can choose from for the inside of the dish, and it comes packaged in a lovely gift box.

Beaded Bracelet with Rosary and Cross

This bracelet is absolutely gorgeous with its rich, deep blue Lapis Lazuli beads, rosary, and cross. Lapis Lazuli is one of the precious stones mentioned throughout the Bible, and has been used for years to bring inner peace and harmony. Each bead measures approximately 6mm and is wrapped in silver wiring, and the cross measures at 3cm.

Leather Bookmark

A nice simple but thoughtful gift, this elegant leather bookmark would be perfect to mark the pages in the Bible, and it is the perfect gift for a church member. It comes with the inspirational message of Jeremiah 29:11, “For I know the plans I have for you” heat debossed on the front. The bookmark is made of brown faux leather with a faux leather knotted cord that hangs from the top.

Promises from God for Women Card Set

The cover of this gift idea is enough to brighten anyone’s spirits, with its soft teal coloring and beautiful floral pattern. Inside this lovely box are 50 double-sided cards that each have wonderfully uplifting messages for you to read and think about as you go about your day. Some of the themes that these daily promise cards address are personal worth, love, hope, strength, and many more. This is a very thoughtful, meaningful gift that any woman would love to start her day with.

Bless this Home Wall Decor

Our home is our safe space, and it’s the place we want to protect the most. So, a beautiful wall decor that says “Bless this home” is sure to invoke positive energy into our space. This sign is not made from stickers or decals, but rather white paint applied directly to a black wooden plank. A stylish way to ensure your favorite place is also your most blessed place.

Stained Glass Musical Jewelry Box

This would be a lovely gift for the members of the church choir! It is a musical jewelry box that plays the infamous song Ave Maria. The cover of the box is a lovely stained glass image, and there are several different images to choose from. You can also select the wooden box in white or mahogany.

Small Rosary Pouch

A simple yet practical gift, any church member would surely appreciate this lovely rosary pouch to carry their beads in. At only 3.5” x 3.5” in size, this pouch can fit in your pocket or purse. It has a beautiful religious image on it and a loop at the end to connect to a key ring or backpack.

Faith Hope and Love Battery Operated Flickering Candles

There is something very calming about candlelight, it creates a peaceful aura in a room. But, sometimes we don’t want to worry about an open flame being hazardous, blowing out, or burning down too quickly. These battery operated flickering candles solve that problem, and the simple messages of faith, hope, and love each inscribed on a different candle make an elegant centerpiece or decoration on any table.

Trust in the Lord Coffee Mug

This coffee mug is decorated with whimsical flowers along the top and bottom, and it also quotes Proverbs 3:5, “Trust in the Lord with all your heart & lean not on your own understanding”. It is made from ceramic with lead-free and cadmium-free glaze that will ensure the pretty design on the mug lasts for years. The mug measures 4.5” tall and comes with a nice gift box for easy gift giving. This can be a particularly nice gift for coffee lovers.

Plush Noah’s Ark with Animals

The perfect gift for your youngest church members! Don’t forget about the little ones, and grab this adorable plush Noah’s Ark! It comes with 3 plush animals as well – an elephant, a zebra, a lion, a tiger, a giraffe, and a leopard. Let them act out one of the most popular Biblical stories with this cute plush set.

3D Crystal Cross Figurine

This beautiful 3D crystal cross figurine would make a lovely addition to any room. With its colorful LED base, the figurine can be lit up with a variety of color choices and color-changing patterns. It comes with a charging cable but can also be operated with three AAA batteries. Due to the cross image being engraved by laser, it will never fade or get worn away.

Six Olive Wood Crosses with Velvet Pouches

At only 4” in size, these little crosses are known as “comfort crosses”, as they are small enough to fit in your pocket for whenever you might need a little of the Lord’s strength and reassurance. Handmade in Bethlehem, the crosses are made from olive wood and the edges are smooth and rounded for a gentle, comforting feel. Each cross comes with its own velvet pouch for safe keeping. As they are made in The Holy Land, each cross also comes with a certificate of origin and a copy of the Lord’s Prayer.

Faith T-shirt

A simple message on a simple t-shirt! This t-shirt comes in a wide variety of colors, allowing you to pick the perfect color for each church member you’re buying for. In delicate cursive, the word “faith” is enveloped within the shape of a cross, leaving a simple but powerful message. Remind your fellow church goers how important it is to keep the faith by gifting them this nice t-shirt.

Trust in the Lord Water Bottle

While it is important to drink lots of water each day, it is also important to remember that the Lord is by our side as we go about our day. So this water bottle makes an excellent gift as it takes care of both of those things. This 28 ounce water bottle comes in a pretty purple color and has the message to trust in the Lord on it. It has a flip-top lid and is BPA-free, making it a great gift for any church member.

Inspirational Scripture Stones

This is a beautiful way to carry a special message with you throughout the day. Each scripture stone is engraved with care to ensure the longevity of the gift, and every stone carries a different message from the Bible. The stones are approximately 2” – 2.5” in size and are made of polished river rocks. They make a great gift for someone to enjoy displayed in their home or carried daily in their pocket.

Willow Tree Angel of Prayer Figurine

Willow Tree figurines are the work of artist Susan Lordi who handcarves the original of every Willow Tree figurine, and then they are replicated in a cast from Susan’s original carving. Once finished, the figurine is then hand painted. Every Willow Tree figurine also comes with an Enclosure Card, and this figurine’s message is “For those who believe in the power of prayer”. A lovely ornament to display on a shelf or table.

Christian Gift Pack from The Holy Land

For someone who has always wanted to travel to The Holy Land but hasn’t been able to, bring The Holy Land to them with this unique and thoughtful gift. This set comes with Holy water from the Jordan river, sacred Holy Land soil from Jerusalem, and olive oil from Bethlehem. The items come packaged in a gift box with an explanation on the back as well as a certificate of authenticity.

Christmas Advent Wooden Prayer Cube

This Christmas Advent cube is a great gift for any church member, especially those who may be teaching Sunday School, as this cube can help with memorizing some of the key prayers. It features prayers for the 4 Sundays in Advent, the Christmas prayer, and Luke 2:10-11. It is a small cube, measuring 1⅝” in size, and is great for encouraging the kids to get involved in Advent.

Praying Angel Figurine with Flameless LED Candle

This is another ornament that also uses the flameless LED candles that can be so convenient to use at times. The candle is surrounded by a praying angel that measures 9” tall and has gorgeous feathered wings that hang down around the candle. It requires three AAA batteries, so be sure to grab some of them before giving this as a gift, as it does not come with any.

Christian Cross Pens (Set of 24)

These Christian cross pens are a great gift to give out to church members, and they are a practical gift as well. The pens come in a variety of colors and write in black ink. They also feature a cross as the pen grip, which is a nice feature. Pass them out to church members on their own, or pair them with a nice note pad or journal.

Set of 12 Inspirational Fridge Magnets

It’s nice to be confronted with an inspirational message throughout our day, and these stylish fridge magnets do just that. With each magnet showing a different message amidst a background of gorgeous colors and patterns, these eye-catching magnets are sure to please. They measure 2.5” x 2.5” and are made of alloy, with smooth corners and sides and a strong magnet to hold on tight with.

Set of 6 Christian Coffee Mugs

Gift giving in bulk! These coffee mugs are each designed with a beautiful floral pattern, each mug a different combination of colors. As well as different colors, each mug also contains a different inspirational message. Take apart this set, and you have a lovely mug to give to six different church members! Fill each mug with some treats or homemade cookies, and you’ve got a lovely, thoughtful gift.

Custom Bible Cover

This custom Bible cover makes a unique and personalized gift. It is made of brown leatherette material and features a zipper closure and a handle for easy carrying. Featuring a large cross on the cover, and the words “Holy Bible” at the top, you can also add up to 2 lines of personalization at the bottom. The company guarantees 100% satisfaction as well.

Olive Wood Wall Cross

This olive wood wall cross makes a stunning addition to any room, and what is so wonderful about it is that each piece of wood features a different line from the Lord’s Prayer. This cross is hand carved in Bethlehem by local artisans, and it measures 8.5” x 5.5”. Each cross is unique, as the coloring and detail is dependent on the pieces of wood selected.

Small Cross Necklace

Made of sterling silver and adorned with cubic zirconia stones, this beautifully dainty piece of jewelry is a perfect gift to give to a special church member. It features a small cross laying sideways along a thin silver chain that measures 18”. The necklace is displayed on a card that reads, “May God watch over you now and forever”.

Box of Blessings

“Let Your Light Shine” box of blessings is a wonderful gift to give to ensure they get a daily dose of inspirational messages! Each card features a beautiful watercolor design and an inspirational scripture message. It makes a lovely gift for your fellow church members, and it will remind them every day of how much they are cared for by our Lord.

If you are looking for the perfect gift to give to a church member, then we hope this list was helpful. With many unique and thoughtful gifts on here, we’re sure you’ll find something each church member will love. Be sure to come back and let us know which gift ideas you decided to go with!